UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY
COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY
COVINGTON DIVISION
IN
RE:
GARY L. DEAN
SHEILA
A. DEAN CASE NO. 99-20705
DEBTOR
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
The matter before the Court
here is a dispute between the debtor and the Chapter 7 trustee. The controversy regards funds the debtor
paid post-petition to the Chapter 13 trustee according to the terms of the
proposed plan up to the point the debtor chose to convert to Chapter 7 proceeding.
After filing this Chapter 13
proceeding on May 3, 1999 and proposing a plan, the debtors elected to convert
to a proceeding under Chapter 7 on September 13, 1999. No plan had been confirmed in their Chapter
13 proceeding. The funds in question are
in the amount of $2,500.00 consisting of post-petition payments made pursuant
to the Chapter 13 plan which, upon conversion, the Chapter 13 trustee turned
over to the Chapter 7 trustee. The
issue is whether funds paid post-petition, pre-confirmation to the Chapter 13
trustee are part of the Chapter 7 estate upon conversion or whether the funds
must be returned to the debtors.
Prior to the enactment of
the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1994 (H.R. 51160), this issue was confusing and
had created a split among the circuits.
Some courts had held that property of the estate in a case converted from
Chapter 13 to Chapter 7 does not include post-petition, pre-conversion earnings
and that such property goes to the debtor.
See In re Luna, 73 B.R. 999 (N.D.Ill. 1987); In re Payne,
88 B.R. 818 (Bankr.E.D.Tenn. 1988).
Other courts had held such earnings to be property of the estate. See In re Brownlee, 93 B.R. 662
(Bankr.S.D.Iowa 1988)(from Chapter 12 to Chapter 7); In re Wanderlich,
36 B.R. 710 (Bankr.W.D.N.Y. 1984);
However, since the 1994
Amendments to the Bankruptcy Code, Public law No. 103-394, '311 (codified as 11 U.S.C. '348(f)), Congress has made
clear that Athe estate in a converted
case consists only of property of the estate as of the date of the original
filing that remains in the possession of the debtor on the date of conversion.@ In re Sandoval, 103 F.3d 20, 23 (5th Cir. 1997);
see also Young v. Key Bank of Maine, et al (In re Young), 66 F.
3rd 376 (1st Cir. 1995).
This Court likewise stated in In Re Hardin, 200 B.R. 312
(Bankr.E.D.Ky. 1996) that the 1994 Amendments have made clear that the debtor=s payments from post-petition
earnings pursuant to a Chapter 13 plan are not part of the Chapter 7 estate
upon conversion.
11 U.S.C. '541 states that the
bankruptcy estate is created upon the commencement of a case and identifies
what is to comprise property of the estate.
For Chapter 13, 11 U.S.C. '1306 expands the estate beyond 11 U.S.C. '541 to include Aall property of the kind
specified in such section [541] that the debtor acquires after the commencement
of the case but before the case is closed, dismissed, or converted...@ 11 U.S.C. '1306(a)(1). Finally, 11 U.S.C. '348(f)(1)(A) provides that
in a converted case the estate consists only of property as of the date of the
petition. Therefore, the funds in
question are not property of the Chapter 7 estate.
Accordingly,
it is hereby ORDERED that the trustee herein pay the funds in question to the
debtors in this proceeding.
Dated this ____ day of
January, 2000.
BY THE COURT
_________________
JUDGE
COPIES
TO:
Chapter
7 Trustee
Chapter
13 Trustee
Debtor
Michael
Plummer, Esq.